I’m just going to say it how it is. Your subject line is fine. That isn’t why nobody opened your email newsletter. If you want to know how to write a newsletter people actually open, read on!

People open newsletters from senders they already trust. Before anyone reads a single word of your subject line, they’ve clocked the sender name and made a subconscious decision. Is this a person I know, or a company that wants something from me? Get that bit right and even the most ordinary subject lines get opened. Get it wrong and the most creative one ever written lands in the folder nobody visits. Open rates are about trust first and copywriting second.

Why does nobody open your newsletter?

Because it sounds like a company, and they can tell before they open it.

Have a scroll through your own inbox. The ones you’ve already opened without thinking are from real people. Names you recognise, writing like they’re writing to you, because they’ve got something worth saying and they’ve stopped pretending to be a brand for five minutes. The ones you don’t open are round-ups. Quarterly updates. Things you didn’t ask for and a header image of a handshake.

(I have a folder that I rarely open. It’s essentially a graveyard with a filing system. Rules are in place: if an email comes from <company name>, file it in my ‘To Read’ folder. My intention is to consume the content, but I admit, I never get around to it.)

The hard truth is that most business owners write the ignorable versions unintentionally on purpose. Not because they can’t write, but because they’ve decided that email is where you’re supposed to sound professional. So the voice that wins them work in a room gets flattened into something that could have come from anyone, and then they blame the subject line when nobody opens it.

What does a newsletter that sounds like a person actually look like?

It looks like a letter. Not a layout. No three-column template. No stock photo of a woman laughing at a laptop. No headers breaking up four hundred words into 50-word bite-sized chunks nobody needed breaking up.

It should be just you, writing properly, about one thing, to one person.

A template gives you somewhere to hide. A blank email doesn’t. If you’ve nothing to say this week, a template will happily help you say nothing beautifully, and your open rate will quietly tell you the truth about it two weeks later!

How do you write a newsletter people open?

Six things. In this order, and trust me, the order matters.

1. Send it from a human name. Christina at Green Umbrella, not Green Umbrella Marketing. This one change does more for your open rate than any subject line you’ll ever agonise over, and it takes seconds to fix in your email marketing software.
2. Write to one person. Pick an actual client. Picture them reading it on their phone at half seven in the morning. Write to them. “You” is singular, and readers can feel the difference between being addressed versus being included in a distribution list.
3. Open with something that’s true. An observation, a mistake you’ve made, a thing a client said last Tuesday that you haven’t stopped thinking about. Not “we hope this email finds you well”. Nobody has ever been found well by a whole group of people in an email.
4. Give them just a few thoughts, not nine. One idea, taken somewhere useful, is better than a bunch of nothingness and endless scrolling.
5. Only add one ask. One. A reply, a reading, a booking. When you offer a multitude of call-to-action buttons, people click none of them. They haven’t got time to make a choice in the moment; they’re on a train and the signal’s pants, or simply because you’ve confused them and they don’t know what they’re supposed to do next!.
6. This is the tough one. Send it before it’s perfect. The imperfection is doing a job. A slightly rough email from a person outperforms a polished one from a committee, every time, and you’ll never test that theory while the draft is sat in your outbox being improved.

What if you’ve been sending the company version for years?

Then say so in the next one. Call it out!

Genuinely. Open the email by naming it: you’ve been sending updates nobody asked for, you’re stopping, here’s what you’ll be sending instead. You’ll get replies. Some of them will be from people you’d assumed had forgotten you existed, and a few of those will turn into the best leads you’ve ever had.

You’ll also get a few unsubscribes, and that’s the point, not the risk. A list of two hundred people who open is worth more than a list of two thousand who’ve trained themselves to scroll past you. Your open rate isn’t a scoreboard. It’s a read on how much your message is landing.

If the wider set-up needs looking at as well as the writing, you can read up here on the commercial side of how email marketing creates sales, and if the deeper problem is that writing as yourself still feels risky, take a look at how to create a personal brand that sells.

Right, then. Pick one client. Open a blank email. Write them 400 words about the thing you’ve been chewing over this week, sign it with your own name, and press send before you’ve had time to tidy it up. That’s the newsletter people open.

Frequently Asked Questions: